Saturday, May 5, 2012

Martin Weller on scholarly blogging.

just as i found myself wondering about the decision to resuscitate--and under a pseudonym? while on the job market? cost/benefit? will i get dooced, now or later?--up pops this guy, claiming that

In terms of intellectual fulfillment, creativity, networking, impact, productivity, and overall benefit to my scholarly life, blogging wins hands down. I have written books, produced online courses, led research efforts, and directed a number of university projects. While these have all been fulfilling, blogging tops the list because of its room for experimentation and potential to connect to timely intelligent debate.

(and, yes, it's from the Chronicle. and yes, i was over there trying to see if there were new wrinkles to the Riley situation. i'll work on diversifying.)

Weller asks some necessary questions about how to recognize blogging and other forms of digital scholarship once "publishing" is a weird verb. per usual, i wonder what will happen to the vanguard in these debates; i've already heard stories--just anecdotes--of colleagues of colleagues whose choice to publish online rather than through traditional channels has hampered tenure achievement, weighed against them in competitive job decisions, etc. Weller himself admits he's published fewer articles since devoting himself to the blog, but professes to enjoy "the establishment of a global peer network that helps me stay up to date with my topic, increased research collaboration, and more invitations to give talks," so much "that it's been worth the trade-off."

he also devotes some space to questions about forms and content. when i started blogging, it was more or less the platform for collecting thoughts online--we weren't podcasting, tweeting, tumblring, or whatever other containers and networks my students are currently enjoying. as i get this thing on its feet, i wonder if it's a dated device, or perhaps not the one best suited to this purpose. which begs the question of if this is about thinking through my own stuff, curating links, maintaining connections, or some soup that involves all of these.

probably that last one, but as i raise this trial balloon, i'll at least try for a mix of thoughtful reflection, open-ended questioning and link collecting. possibly also some kitten videos.

and: here's Weller's blog.

Friday, May 4, 2012

the riley debate.

i'm going to assume anyone who cares to read this blog knows something about the debate surrounding Naomi Schaefer Riley's "The Most Persuasive Case for Eliminating Black Studies?  Just Read the Dissertations."  (if you don't, it shouldn't take you long; the piece is a quick read, although the unease it provokes may be long-lasting.)  the Northwestern grad students' response is courageous and, for the most part, admirably measured (not that restraint is the most appropriate or acceptable reaction; more on that in a minute).   the faculty response is as professional as you'd expect, and directs traffic to the Chron's original piece on the subject, which risks obscurity in the midst of some very disturbing rhetoric.

i first became aware of the incendiary blog post when a Facebook friend's feed linked to a petition calling for Riley's dismissal.  i was a little reticent, even after i read the piece, which seems to me horrifying not only in its willful disregard for the clear lacunae that Af-Am and Black Studies seek, in part, to address, but in the glee Riley takes in her own willingness to sling some serious accusation  without much interrogation.  specifically, that is, on a platform associated with the Chronicle, a publication which ostensibly owes some fealty to the standards of critical thinking and interrogation academics profess to . . . well, profess.  this hit piece would still have been objectionable had it been featured by some other, mass-market publication, but in association with, the Chron, it seems outlandish.  there's probably a side conversation to be had, here, about what  difference might exist between the blog(posts) the Chron hosts and what the journal (paper?) "publishes," but the content seems so irresponsible that it overwhelms quibbles over their responsibility.  Liz McMillen's editor's note, which reads in part:

"[The Brainstorm blog] is a blog for opinion, sometimes strong opinions, not news reporting by the staff. The writers on the blog—13 in all, from institutions around the country—fall on different points of the ideological and political spectrum. They are not staff members of The Chronicle nor do they represent the views of the staff or of the newspaper. . . .  I urge readers instead to view this posting as an opportunity—to debate Riley’s views, challenge her, set things straight as you see fit."

seems overwhelmingly unsatisfying, particularly when it conflates "strong opinion" with the sort of specific, unfounded attacks that characterize Riley's piece.  why, exactly, would the Chronicle be interested in any opinion that so blatantly mocks the academy's supposed commitment to critical thought, careful argument and productive discussion? Riley's piece is shocking in its disregard for scholarship.  the Chronicle, given its commitments and focus, is at best an awkward context for it.  worse, there's no real "opportunity" to do the challenging and debating McMillen suggests.  in the comments?  too much of the comment section is a wasteland of briefly considered jabs, interspersed with some thoughtful attempts at discourse, and on the whole nearly impossible to navigate.

still, i was reticent about signing that petition. 

Thursday, August 20, 2009

is you is or is you ain't?


the caster semenya debate (is she a woman?) seems almost like a performance studies case file. i don't mean to assume any identification for her, conventional or non-, but continue to marvel that in the face of so much evidence that gender and sex simply can't be accounted for by a binary, debate still centers around the is/isn't she armwrestle rather than a suggestion of a continuum (or series of venn diagrams, or a polymap, or . . . whatever someone smart is going to come up with next).

my favorite quote: “For me, she is not a woman" (Italy's Elisa Piccione, an eclisped competitor). not that it's contingent, or anything.

(also interesting? that image, which i shamelessly ganked from the site cited below, has a default file name that starts with "BOY2". someone's decided.)


story via the UK times online.

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

senior cyborgs, robot unemployment.

"In a sport tarnished by doping scandals, the older athletes raise anew the question of what constitutes a natural body for people who are at an age when drugs are a part of life."

and: "Japan’s legions of robots, the world’s largest fleet of mechanized workers, are having a tough time finding work as the country suffers its deepest recession in more than a generation."

particularly interesting locution on the last story . . . a generation of mechanized workers? o, the humanity.

both via the new york times, registration may be required (try bugmenot).

Thursday, November 13, 2008

utopian times.

via my friend pasha, thank god the war is over! not to mention DeBeers giving free prosthetics to victims of "diamond conflicts" violence, which actually had me fooled.

Monday, November 10, 2008

neat avatar stuff

virtual transgender suit: http://www.we-make-money-not-art.com/archives/2008/08/marc-owens-who-designed-the.php

girlfriend experience (the prostitutes who get paid the most pretend to be your gf--affective labor, simulation/illusion: http://www.we-make-money-not-art.com/archives/2007/01/martin-butler-p.php

avatar machine: http://www.we-make-money-not-art.com/archives/2007/06/the-virtual-com.php

Sunday, November 9, 2008

butler on obama.

look, no promises, but this was good enough to make me peek my head out of blogretirement. those of you who care have probably already seen it, but it was nice to get the feeling that i'm not the only one who can't look at a political rally (even a relatively awesome, pro-obama one) without flashing back to Triumph of the Will. si se puede, for sure, but also: eeep.